

Osteoporosis is today a major problem and is still little understood. Bernard looks at why bone density is only one factor in fracture risk, and why strength, flexibility, nutrients and movement matter more.
There’s an amazing balance within the body between two opposing forces, which in Chinese Traditional medicine are referred to as Yin and Yang. We can observe this balance in the interplay between the sympathetic and parasympathetic system, clotting and anti-clotting factors, in-breath and out-breath, acid-producing and alkaline-producing factors, temperature-raising and temperature-lowering factors.
Every movement within the body has its counter movement. This balance is referred to as ‘homeostasis’. When this homeostasis is out of balance, when there is a predominance of one movement over the other, then ill-health slowly or rapidly becomes apparent.
There is always an intrinsic dance to bring the system back to its primary homeostatic balance. Doctors of Integrative Medicine are very much aware of this process and refer to it as the system's own innate intelligence. Every effort is made to work with this intelligence, as it is understood that body systems are intelligent and will heal if the blocks to the healing are removed and the nutritional deficiencies are boosted.
Osteoporosis is today a major problem and is still little understood. There are osteoblast or bone forming cells and osteoclasts or bone removing cells. Although osteoporosis is often thought to be a problem of ageing, in Japan with one of the longest lifespans of any population the rate of hip fractures is two and half times less than the United States, and this despite the Japanese’s lower intake of calcium.
Nor is osteoporosis universally linked to menopause. Despite the fact that in all women hormone levels fall, not all women develop osteoporosis. This suggests that other factors are also important. In fact women start losing bone calcium long before menopause.
Bone is a dynamic living tissue which is constantly being broken down and rebuilt, even in adults. It is a storehouse of minerals, particularly calcium, and will obviously be affected by the need of the body to maintain a strong structure on the one hand and the body’s need for minerals and calcium on the other hand. Exercise and hard physical work will motivate the body to increase the strength of the bones while a deficient diet will cause minerals to be extracted from the bone to supply the body with these essential minerals.
The World Health Organization defines osteoporosis based on a T-score of –2,5 or lower on a DEXA scan. But this threshold, while statistically derived, isn’t destiny. All statistical normals are based on studies of large numbers of people, usually in a small number of countries, and then setting a cut-off point for what is normal and what is abnormal. This is what is meant by ‘statistically derived’ and may have little to do with you as an individual.
A low BMD score does not automatically equal fragility, nor is it the sole predictor of future fracture risk. Even more critically, there’s growing evidence that functional strength – especially relative to body weight – is far more important in determining real-world risk than a Dual-Energy X-ray Absorptiometry (DEXA) scan suggests
Myth 1: A low bone density score automatically means a high risk of fracture. Not true. As already indicated, density of bone does not mean strength and flexibility. Fracture rates vary enormously in different countries, even when there is a similarity in bone density scores.
Myth 2: Calcium and vitamin D3 are enough to strengthen bones and increase density. As indicated already, calcium may increase density but that is not a criteria for bone strength. Most people get enough calcium in their diets and while vitamin D certainly increases calcium absorption, that calcium may not go to the bones without the presence of vitamin K2, and instead may end up in the blood vessels leading to atherosclerosis.
Myth 3: Only women suffer from osteoporosis. Hormones do make a difference to bone density, and falling hormones do seem to have an influence on bone density and strength. Nevertheless fractures occur equally in both sexes in those with low and normal density. Again, density is not the main criterion to predict fractures.
In a 2004 study published in Bone, researchers found that more than 60% of all fractures in older women occurred in those without an osteoporosis diagnosis – that is, with T-scores above -2,5. This data highlights a critical flaw in how we interpret bone density: it’s only one piece of the puzzle
Myth 4: The treatment myth. Bone targeting drugs, such as bisphosphonates prescribed by most doctors once they have this diagnosis, have unproven or restricted anti-fracture efficacy and come with long-term and widespread safety concerns, including rare but severe events such as atypical femoral fractures.
Bone-building versus Bone-thinning factors
Bone building factors include adequate quantities of all essential nutrients, healthy and well-balanced endocrine gland functioning, appropriate levels of exercise and activity and well-balanced body chemistry.
Bone thinning factors are many and while the fall in hormones may play a part, it is only one of the factors involved. In a similar way we begin to recognize that high cholesterol is only one of the risk factors for heart disease and not necessarily the most important one.
Osteoporosis will only occur when the bone-depleting factors are more prominent than the total bone building forces. Each step one takes to remove a bone-depleting factor is one more step to creating a stronger bone.
Bone strength vs bone density: Lead in a pencil, which is very dense, breaks easily if dropped. In the same, density does not mean bone strength. This is the problem with diagnostic scans which measure bone density. Density is suggestive only, but many other factors are responsible for bone strength.
Density does not allow for flexibility, which is so important and may be the primary factor preventing fractures. Flexibility is required for twisting and bending without breaking.
Bone contains an elastic living matrix made of protein called collagen, and it is this collagen which makes all the difference.
Calcium, magnesium, boron and other minerals give bone the density and collagen gives it the flexibility. Osteoporosis as defined by conventional medical doctors may not be the primary cause of fractures. It’s a good story, with diagnostic labelling using bone scans. But they tell us nothing about bone strength, only density.
The diagnosis is then used to justify drug treatment and the treatment used may increase density, but not strength. There is even some evidence that the increased density may increase fractures.
Risk factors for osteoporosis include the following:
Inactivity
Disorders of the liver and kidney
Family history of osteoporosis
Drugs (steroids, anticonvulsants, antacids)
Smoking
Heavy alcohol use
Stomach or small bowel resection
Postmenopause and premature menopause
Short stature and small bones
Vitamin D deficiency
Hyperparathyroidism and hyperthyroidism
Dietary factors:
More than two cups of coffee per day
Consuming excess meat daily
Drinking carbonated drinks regularly
Consuming less than three servings of vegetables including at least 1 cup of green leafy vegetables per day, high salt intake, high intake of refined sugar.
Management
Strange but true, lifestyle management is still the best way to go, and this includes food choices of fresh fruit and vegetables, dairy products, eggs, meat and fish and away from processed foods.
All exercise is essential and especially weight bearing and strength training.
Avoid being sedentary for long periods, and move around as much as possible.
Extra nutrients such as vitamin D3 in high doses, magnesium in high doses, a good source of amino acids and collagen. I don't usually add calcium as I believe that most people have sufficient calcium in their diet and the vitamin D3 helps calcium absorption. Vitamin K2 is needed to move the calcium into the bones.
Conclusion
Bone density in the end is just one factor in the assessment of future fractures, and using drugs to increase density is therefore not a good idea, especially in the long run and when side effects are present. They may even increase the risk of fractures.
The main cause for fractures in the elderly is not osteoporosis, but falling. The older one gets the greater the risk of falling and this is not due to bone thinning but rather muscular strength and general stability on one's feet.
Bone density is just one factor and not the most important one. Adding another drug to the elderly without pointing out the real importance of nutrients and exercise is not good medicine.
Continue exploring



